PowerSwitch

A five-year extension to the Sellafield nuclear decommissioning contract worth £5bn was handed to a private consortium even though its performance had been fiercely criticised by accountants.

KPMG, working for the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority, accused the clean-up group of overspending, failure to reach operational targets and weak leadership at the atomic complex in Cumbria, according to documents seen by the Guardian.

Margaret Hodge, who chairs the parliament's public accounts committee, said that in the light of the critical review it was "inexplicable" that the NDA was prepared to reward the Nuclear Management Partners (NMP) consortium for spending cash "like confetti".

She also complained the critical KPMG report was not shown to her committee or the National Audit Office until the last minute. It had only been sent to the spending watchdogs via a member of the public who conducted a freedom of information request. "But having looked at the report it is inexplicable that the NDA would continue with this consortium after such a hugely critical assessment," she added.

The NMP decommissioning consortium comprises Areva, the French engineering firm that is also working on the new Hinkley Point power station, in Somerset, which also includes URS of the US and Amec of Britain.

KPMG says it went through 28 out of 154 "bid commitments" at Sellafield and found 30% were deemed fully achieved and 4% partially achieved. KPMG added: "There is still considerable uncertainty in schedules and costs of the projects that account for 26% of annual spending" while the site manager "does not bear risks for delays and cost increases".

RenewableCandy wrote:I don't think it's fair to comment on the Carbon intensity of nuclear power 'til we know for sure exactly how decommissioning and waste disposal are going to be done. For all we know, these might cause so much Carbon as to tip up the entire set of figures.

As UK Nuclear News is about to enter its 9th year we believe it is now an important part of the energy political landscape. It is delivered almost every day of the year, to journalists, academics, campaigners and energy professionals.

We are pleased to say that thanks to the generosity of some of our readers we have managed to maintain UK Nuclear News as a free daily news service. We now need you to be generous once again, and for those who haven’t contributed yet to consider doing so. You will know the service is saving you time and probably money searching for the news yourself. At this crucial time in the nuclear debate we would like to keep this going as a free service funded by voluntary donations, because it makes it cheaper for everyone.

It costs us around £7,500 every year to produce UK Daily Nuclear News, and manage the news pages and searchable archive on the website. We are very grateful to Greenpeace for the assistance they give, but unfortunately this is not enough to cover our costs. Last year we raised almost half of our target altogether, so we are currently running at a loss.

PLEASE HELP by donating what you can. If half of our subscribers were able to donate £30 every year (less than 10p per issue), that would help to keep our heads above water.

You can send cheques, made payable to "no2nuclearpower", to Pete Roche c/o Friends of the Earth Scotland, Thorn House, 5 Rose Street, Edinburgh EH2 2PR.

Or you can donate by PayPal. For details see here! : www.no2nuclearpower.org.uk/help/donations.php

If you want to donate via internet banking, send me an e-mail to pete@no2nuclearpower.org.uk and I’ll send you the bank details.

Thanks in anticipation.