Brexit process
Moderator: Peak Moderation
- UndercoverElephant
- Posts: 13654
- Joined: 10 Mar 2008, 00:00
- Location: UK
So, today is the day the wheels come off the Johnsonmobile!
Parliament is going to pass legislation making no deal illegal, even though it will cost at least a handful of tory MPs their careers. Johnson will try to call an election under the FTPA and Labour will whip against it, citing the need to make sure no deal is prevented.
This is like some judo move where you use your opponents momentum against them. Instead of engaging for the fight, Labour just unexpectedly steps out of the way, leaving Johnson's brexit strategy in tatters. Can't leave with no deal (illegal), can't leave with May's deal, can't get May's deal changed, can't get an election before October 31st even though all trace of a working majority blown to smithereens. He can't even deselect Hammond, whose constituency party has just reselected him.
Johnson will then be forced to ask for the article 50 extension he's repeatedly declared he won't ask for under any circumstances, and Nigel Farage will make hay in the sunshine. Then as soon as the extension is granted, Labour will VonC the government, and win. Absolute class!
Parliament is going to pass legislation making no deal illegal, even though it will cost at least a handful of tory MPs their careers. Johnson will try to call an election under the FTPA and Labour will whip against it, citing the need to make sure no deal is prevented.
This is like some judo move where you use your opponents momentum against them. Instead of engaging for the fight, Labour just unexpectedly steps out of the way, leaving Johnson's brexit strategy in tatters. Can't leave with no deal (illegal), can't leave with May's deal, can't get May's deal changed, can't get an election before October 31st even though all trace of a working majority blown to smithereens. He can't even deselect Hammond, whose constituency party has just reselected him.
Johnson will then be forced to ask for the article 50 extension he's repeatedly declared he won't ask for under any circumstances, and Nigel Farage will make hay in the sunshine. Then as soon as the extension is granted, Labour will VonC the government, and win. Absolute class!
Not so sure, although we will know by tonight.UndercoverElephant wrote:So, today is the day the wheels come off the Johnsonmobile!
Depends how many labour MP's fear/respect/agree with their vote leaving constituencies.
And how many Tory MP's have a spine to genuinely vote according to their conscience.
Nothing is certain in these febrile times.
I would absolutely not be surprised if the emergency motion to take control of the order paper fails. It's going to be really close. Labour Leave vs Tory Remain will decide the future.
It now seems to suit all anti-no-deal MPs to avoid a GE before October 31st if they do get the anti-no-deal law through. They surely want to enforce BJ's Oct 31 failure first before going to the people.
But what do we think about the possibility of the govt trying to repeal the FTPA? No 2/3 majority needed for that option. I mean, it'll seem really cynical and self-serving, but what doesn't these days? It's all-out political war by any means necessary and possible.
Anyway, I still suspect the emergency motion may fail due to Labour Leavers and wobbly Tory Remainers, in which case we all get to see how no-deal works out in practice.
It now seems to suit all anti-no-deal MPs to avoid a GE before October 31st if they do get the anti-no-deal law through. They surely want to enforce BJ's Oct 31 failure first before going to the people.
But what do we think about the possibility of the govt trying to repeal the FTPA? No 2/3 majority needed for that option. I mean, it'll seem really cynical and self-serving, but what doesn't these days? It's all-out political war by any means necessary and possible.
Anyway, I still suspect the emergency motion may fail due to Labour Leavers and wobbly Tory Remainers, in which case we all get to see how no-deal works out in practice.
Last edited by RevdTess on 03 Sep 2019, 12:22, edited 1 time in total.
That is a very interesting observation and one I had not consideredRevdTess wrote:...But what do we think about the possibility of the govt trying to repeal the FTPA? No 2/3 majority needed for that option. I mean, it'll seem really cynical and self-serving, but what doesn't these days? It's all-out political war by any means necessary and possible....
Will he bollocks. His principles have been progressively jettisoned over the course of the last three years. His only goal now is power at any cost. Thus, he will have worked out, along with other Remainers, than an election right now could easily go The Tories way. I suspect he may well instruct Labour MPs to now vote against a VoNC.Snail wrote:If labour vote against a general election, I wonder if Jeremy Corbyn will feel an obligation to resign.
- UndercoverElephant
- Posts: 13654
- Joined: 10 Mar 2008, 00:00
- Location: UK
That's exactly why it won't happen right now. (EDIT: I changed my mind, see below)RevdTess wrote: But what do we think about the possibility of the govt trying to repeal the FTPA? No 2/3 majority needed for that option.
Last edited by UndercoverElephant on 03 Sep 2019, 14:26, edited 1 time in total.
- UndercoverElephant
- Posts: 13654
- Joined: 10 Mar 2008, 00:00
- Location: UK
Actually I have changed my mind.Little John wrote:why what won't happen?UndercoverElephant wrote:That's exactly why it won't happen right now.RevdTess wrote: But what do we think about the possibility of the govt trying to repeal the FTPA? No 2/3 majority needed for that option.
If Labour doesn't vote for an election (which looks guaranteed now, according to various tweets flying around), then the tories have two options available to them. They can either call a VonC in themselves, or they can repeal the FTPA. They could conceivably try either.
- Lord Beria3
- Posts: 5066
- Joined: 25 Feb 2009, 20:57
- Location: Moscow Russia
- Contact:
https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/ar ... s_aug_2019
UE - read this and weep.
Blondemoney calling it for hard Brexit and ge after 31st October.
As eurointeligence says today boris would rather go to jail then extend article 50.
UE - read this and weep.
Blondemoney calling it for hard Brexit and ge after 31st October.
As eurointeligence says today boris would rather go to jail then extend article 50.
Peace always has been and always will be an intermittent flash of light in a dark history of warfare, violence, and destruction
- Lord Beria3
- Posts: 5066
- Joined: 25 Feb 2009, 20:57
- Location: Moscow Russia
- Contact:
- Lord Beria3
- Posts: 5066
- Joined: 25 Feb 2009, 20:57
- Location: Moscow Russia
- Contact:
BlondeMoney analysis:
Boris landslide election win after No Deal Brexit
Boris' speech tonight was aimed at the public. He will deliver Brexit by 31st October and then deliver his Reaganite domestic agenda.
To win big, he must provoke anger and re-run the referendum's totemic The People vs The Elites campaign.
TIMELINE:
Government to lose Extension vote by 7 votes
BlondeMoney Prediction as of 7.30pm 2 Sept 2019
Boris vows to ignore it, brings on battle with the judiciary
Calls Remainers’ bluff and brings forward dissolution of Parliament for Oct 14th election
Labour anti-Corbyn moderates vote against Boris’ dissolution
Boris wins election after 31st October No Deal, backing The People over The Elites
This strategy:
Exposes Labour’s split
Exposes Tory Rebels
Exposes lack of tools to prevent No Deal
Peace always has been and always will be an intermittent flash of light in a dark history of warfare, violence, and destruction