Scotland Watch

Discussion of the latest Peak Oil news (please also check the Website News area below)

Moderator: Peak Moderation

User avatar
UndercoverElephant
Posts: 13496
Joined: 10 Mar 2008, 00:00
Location: UK

Post by UndercoverElephant »

biffvernon wrote:
John Lennon wrote:Imagine there's no countries
It isn't hard to do
Nothing to kill or die for
...
You may say I'm dreamer
But I'm not the only one
I hope some day you'll join me
And the wo..er...er...erld will continue down exactly the same path to oblivion, leaving the dreamers splattered like flies on a windscreen
User avatar
Mr. Fox
Posts: 669
Joined: 24 Nov 2005, 11:09
Location: In the Dark - looking for my socks

Post by Mr. Fox »

:D

With any luck there will be an immigrant with a bucket and squeegee at the next set of traffic lights...
Tarrel
Posts: 2466
Joined: 29 Nov 2011, 22:32
Location: Ross-shire, Scotland
Contact:

Post by Tarrel »

Just got back from a screening of "Scotland Yet", an independently made film about the independence debate which, I believe, captures some of the ideas that various posters in this thread have tried to express about the Scottish mindset vis-a-vis independence.

You can watch it online here: www.scotlandyet.com, but beware, it's 90 minutes long.

The film's sound track was produced by a wonderful partnership of Scottish fiddle and Swedish mandolin players. The fiddle player, Rona Wilkie, grew up in our area and went to the local secondary school. They came back and performed a concert in the school earlier this year, which was excellent.

http://maritandrona.co.uk/

If you have 90 minutes spare I highly recommend the film as a way of understanding more about where the "Yes" campaign is coming from. It may not change your opinion, but it certainly deepens understanding.

("Seek first to understand, before being understood." - Stephen Covey.)

The film illustrates a deep disillusionment with mainstream Westminster politics, starting with Thatcherisation in the late 70's, fuelled further by the missed opportunities of the Blair years. One of my favourite quotes from the film, by David Greig, playwright:
The referendum asks; "Does Scotland want to be independent. In a way, it's an old-fashioned question. It's asking something else. It's asking; "Do you want to start again? Do you want to re-think what a country should be in the 21st century?"
The film pointed to the positive impact that the debate has had on engagement in the political process, and the re-emergence of town hall politics, irrespective of voting intention. It described packed village halls with people eager to debate, which was interesting, as we were watching the film in a packed village hall, on a Saturday night, with X-Factor on TV. Mind you, it may have had something to do with the excellent homemade shortbread on offer! The youngest person in the room looked about six, the oldest well into their 80's.
Engage in geo-engineering. Plant a tree today.
Tarrel
Posts: 2466
Joined: 29 Nov 2011, 22:32
Location: Ross-shire, Scotland
Contact:

Post by Tarrel »

Mr. Fox wrote::D

With any luck there will be an immigrant with a bucket and squeegee at the next set of traffic lights...
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Engage in geo-engineering. Plant a tree today.
Tarrel
Posts: 2466
Joined: 29 Nov 2011, 22:32
Location: Ross-shire, Scotland
Contact:

Post by Tarrel »

Latest YouGov poll shows the "Yes" campaign ahead for the first time.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-s ... s-29093956
Engage in geo-engineering. Plant a tree today.
peaceful_life
Posts: 544
Joined: 21 Sep 2010, 16:20

Post by peaceful_life »

UndercoverElephant wrote:
biffvernon wrote:
John Lennon wrote:Imagine there's no countries
It isn't hard to do
Nothing to kill or die for
...
You may say I'm dreamer
But I'm not the only one
I hope some day you'll join me
And the wo..er...er...erld will continue down exactly the same path to oblivion, leaving the dreamers splattered like flies on a windscreen
More than probable, but it's about the journey.

Try another shot at that philosophy thing.
Little John

Post by Little John »

another_exlurker wrote:Steve, most of those agricultural workers aren't married and don't have kids. Also, the farms usually provide accommodation of some kind (usually static caravans). As far as I'm aware, agricultural accommodation that is located on the farm doesn't attract council tax if it's for farm employees. There usually isn't any rent to pay either (hence why the wages are lower).

One of the reasons why the farms have to rely on immigrant workers is because, traditionally, those jobs were done by migrant workers from within the UK. Thanks to Maggie destroying the traveller community, that whole way of life was (to all intent and purpose) completely destroyed.
exactly. We are all, apart from a few fuckers at the top, dancing to a tune not of our making, where we must each of us F--k the next guy over in order to stay afloat.

The problem is systemic
Little John

Post by Little John »

Tarrel wrote:Latest YouGov poll shows the "Yes" campaign ahead for the first time.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-s ... s-29093956
Bloody hell.
kenneal - lagger
Site Admin
Posts: 14290
Joined: 20 Sep 2006, 02:35
Location: Newbury, Berkshire
Contact:

Post by kenneal - lagger »

Mr. Fox wrote:What problem? :?
This problem

OK, they are not eligible for benefits when they get here but stories of the benefits available must make this country sound like a land of milk and honey. Every migrant who comes here makes it more difficult for a person already here to get a job. Every migrant who come here lowers the wages available for those who are already here. Every migrant who comes here lowers the potential standard of living of those who are already here. Every migrant who comes here and lives ten or more to a room, hot bedding, makes it more likely that those who are already here will have to do the same at some time in the future. the fact that these are all illegal immigrants means that they will work for peanuts and be better off.

Migrants are in competition with those at the bottom of the pile already and Steve has already pointed out what their lot might be
Many of them are short term migrant workers who work in industries like agriculture and other seasonal sectors. these sectors previously employed low skilled British workers. Those people are, by virtue of the the way our society is set up, required to have permanent address, send their kids to school etc. This means that they are subject to costs of living that are more or less inescapable. Things such as rent, council tax water rates and all the rest. This means that the wages on offer by farmers and other seasonal employers simply do not meet those costs. Any employer who chooses to employ indigenous British workers alone on decent wages that meet such costs will be firstly immediately economically disadvantaged by other employers who choose to employ low paid migrants and, secondly, he/she may well be subject to EU anti-discrimination employment laws. And so, all employers are dragged to the party of low pay and conditions for workers whether they like it or not.

Even when such workers are not short term migrants, it is hardly uprising, if they have come from an economic basket case of a country, that they will put up with shitty pay and conditions and keep their mouths shut and not complain. The UK, as it happens, had a booming economy during most of the Victorian Era. The lot of most workers during that period consisted of hard lives that were considerably shorter than had been the case in the period immediately prior to the industrial revolution. Only when unions formed and pushed for better pay and conditions did things change. Even then it took a couple of wars and thousands of men marching home having been trained to kill people with guns, before our elites finally were scared enough to give some ground. It's only surprising it has taken the bastards 70 odd years to begin to seriously claw it all back.
I thought it worth repeating.

Tarrel, Carlisle will only become another Calais if the Scots rebuild Hadrian's Wall or dig a very wide moat!
Action is the antidote to despair - Joan Baez
User avatar
biffvernon
Posts: 18538
Joined: 24 Nov 2005, 11:09
Location: Lincolnshire
Contact:

Post by biffvernon »

kenneal - lagger wrote: Every migrant who comes here makes it more difficult for a person already here to get a job.
I think that is a fundamental error. There is not a fixed number of jobs in the economy. If a Romanian comes here and picks cabbages it allows jobs to be created in the cabbage distribution and retailing system.
vtsnowedin
Posts: 6595
Joined: 07 Jan 2011, 22:14
Location: New England ,Chelsea Vermont

Post by vtsnowedin »

kenneal - lagger wrote: Tarrel, Carlisle will only become another Calais if the Scots rebuild Hadrian's Wall or dig a very wide moat!
Now there is a public works project you could sink your teeth into. Why just the permitting process alone would waste tens of billions and pad the retirements of hundreds of bureaucrats.
OrraLoon
Posts: 436
Joined: 16 Jun 2007, 15:57
Location: Mittelschottland

Post by OrraLoon »

UndercoverElephant wrote:hold on to your gold. Its day will come.
:)

Now where have I heard that slogan before?

I can't absolutely tell you what the result is going to be – but the No campaign have definitely lost control.How many more celebrities, ex-footballers, world leaders and businessmen are there to wheel out to deter us?
In some ways it might actually be better to have a 47-48% Yes vote now, let Boris and UKIP do their worst for the next 4-5 years, then breeze through with a 1998-style 60% + vote in the re-run. Less divisive. Bur would we get a re-run any time soon?
Slightly off-topic: I've been reading bits and pieces about Cromwell enforcing his 'Commonwealth' in these parts. Funnily enough he wasn't too keen on the Union Jack because of its Royalist connotations. They tried one or two other things including a compination with a harp planked on top. So you could say that there always have been stresses in the Unionist camp. Now I'd better go before I lapse into xenophobic ranting about English-Spanish stitch-ups, 1699, and history repeating itself…

[But if I haven't said it before I'm gonna love it when Flanders becomes independent, gets kicked out of the EU, and the politicians and bureaucrats in Brussels need to have their sandwiches flown in by helicopter.]
Give me a place to stand on and I will move the Earth.
peaceful_life
Posts: 544
Joined: 21 Sep 2010, 16:20

Post by peaceful_life »

kenneal - lagger wrote:
Mr. Fox wrote:What problem? :?
This problem

OK, they are not eligible for benefits when they get here but stories of the benefits available must make this country sound like a land of milk and honey. Every migrant who comes here makes it more difficult for a person already here to get a job. Every migrant who come here lowers the wages available for those who are already here. Every migrant who comes here lowers the potential standard of living of those who are already here. Every migrant who comes here and lives ten or more to a room, hot bedding, makes it more likely that those who are already here will have to do the same at some time in the future. the fact that these are all illegal immigrants means that they will work for peanuts and be better off.

Migrants are in competition with those at the bottom of the pile already and Steve has already pointed out what their lot might be
Many of them are short term migrant workers who work in industries like agriculture and other seasonal sectors. these sectors previously employed low skilled British workers. Those people are, by virtue of the the way our society is set up, required to have permanent address, send their kids to school etc. This means that they are subject to costs of living that are more or less inescapable. Things such as rent, council tax water rates and all the rest. This means that the wages on offer by farmers and other seasonal employers simply do not meet those costs. Any employer who chooses to employ indigenous British workers alone on decent wages that meet such costs will be firstly immediately economically disadvantaged by other employers who choose to employ low paid migrants and, secondly, he/she may well be subject to EU anti-discrimination employment laws. And so, all employers are dragged to the party of low pay and conditions for workers whether they like it or not.

Even when such workers are not short term migrants, it is hardly uprising, if they have come from an economic basket case of a country, that they will put up with shitty pay and conditions and keep their mouths shut and not complain. The UK, as it happens, had a booming economy during most of the Victorian Era. The lot of most workers during that period consisted of hard lives that were considerably shorter than had been the case in the period immediately prior to the industrial revolution. Only when unions formed and pushed for better pay and conditions did things change. Even then it took a couple of wars and thousands of men marching home having been trained to kill people with guns, before our elites finally were scared enough to give some ground. It's only surprising it has taken the bastards 70 odd years to begin to seriously claw it all back.
I thought it worth repeating.

Tarrel, Carlisle will only become another Calais if the Scots rebuild Hadrian's Wall or dig a very wide moat!
Let's thread some truth into this, the word 'migrant' is a cognitive dupe to dehumanise, these folk are 'blow-back' victims of social engineering courtesy of the highest brutality dished out in order to maintain that illusion of milk and honey you refer to and the whole façade serves nothing but that systemic fig-leaf in cloaking a minority privilege, it's not even utilitarian.....it's good old fashion greed born of economic/ecological illiteracy.
Masters of the universe, I think not, more like abstract abracadabra.
User avatar
biffvernon
Posts: 18538
Joined: 24 Nov 2005, 11:09
Location: Lincolnshire
Contact:

Post by biffvernon »

peaceful_life wrote:the word 'migrant' is a cognitive dupe to dehumanise,
Exactly so.
User avatar
UndercoverElephant
Posts: 13496
Joined: 10 Mar 2008, 00:00
Location: UK

Post by UndercoverElephant »

biffvernon wrote:
kenneal - lagger wrote: Every migrant who comes here makes it more difficult for a person already here to get a job.
I think that is a fundamental error. There is not a fixed number of jobs in the economy. If a Romanian comes here and picks cabbages it allows jobs to be created in the cabbage distribution and retailing system.
Erm....no.

If the Romanian didn't come here then a British person would be employed to pick the cabbage and precisely the same number of other jobs would exist.
Post Reply