Just got back from a screening of "Scotland Yet", an independently made film about the independence debate which, I believe, captures some of the ideas that various posters in this thread have tried to express about the Scottish mindset vis-a-vis independence.
You can watch it online here:
www.scotlandyet.com, but beware, it's 90 minutes long.
The film's sound track was produced by a wonderful partnership of Scottish fiddle and Swedish mandolin players. The fiddle player, Rona Wilkie, grew up in our area and went to the local secondary school. They came back and performed a concert in the school earlier this year, which was excellent.
http://maritandrona.co.uk/
If you have 90 minutes spare I highly recommend the film as a way of understanding more about where the "Yes" campaign is coming from. It may not change your opinion, but it certainly deepens understanding.
("Seek first to understand, before being understood." - Stephen Covey.)
The film illustrates a deep disillusionment with mainstream Westminster politics, starting with Thatcherisation in the late 70's, fuelled further by the missed opportunities of the Blair years. One of my favourite quotes from the film, by David Greig, playwright:
The referendum asks; "Does Scotland want to be independent. In a way, it's an old-fashioned question. It's asking something else. It's asking; "Do you want to start again? Do you want to re-think what a country should be in the 21st century?"
The film pointed to the positive impact that the debate has had on engagement in the political process, and the re-emergence of town hall politics, irrespective of voting intention. It described packed village halls with people eager to debate, which was interesting, as we were watching the film in a packed village hall, on a Saturday night, with X-Factor on TV. Mind you, it may have had something to do with the excellent homemade shortbread on offer! The youngest person in the room looked about six, the oldest well into their 80's.
Engage in geo-engineering. Plant a tree today.